weak or strong?

In my lit circle group all three of us placed out character in the middle. This is because she was never mentally stable, and still isn't. But that never stopped her form physically acting. By the show of her actions towards Maxon.

I placed it in the middle because she is physically strong. But in the mental strait she is no were near strong. Defiantly with the whole Aspen thing and him being closer to her now. She is a mental wreck. For example she had a brake down near the middle of the book when she was talking to Maxon about her secret relationship with aspen and when he broke up with her, this shows her week side. Her physical strong side showed when she hit Maxon in the garden wall on a walk/date.